]> git.ozlabs.org Git - ccan/commit
htable: increase density from 75% to 87.5%
authorRusty Russell <rusty@rustcorp.com.au>
Fri, 17 Jun 2022 04:33:53 +0000 (14:03 +0930)
committerRusty Russell <rusty@rustcorp.com.au>
Fri, 17 Jun 2022 04:33:53 +0000 (14:03 +0930)
commit3fcc6bfb0447e07a69c4912951021a4104a6f726
tree99d3389090349c706d6499ed084bc85f8e72bd9c
parentd10966dc916931204b5e4f734ed08e9e793a8774
htable: increase density from 75% to 87.5%

Across all benchmarks (on various sizes) this actually drops
performance by 3%.  However, density increasing by 15% is probably a
worthwhile tradeoff.

```
-Initial insert: 227-237(230+/-3.7) ns
+Initial insert: 266-281(273.4+/-6.5) ns
-Initial lookup (match): 65-66(65.4+/-0.49) ns
+Initial lookup (match): 67-78(70.6+/-3.8) ns
-Initial lookup (miss): 79-80(79.4+/-0.49) ns
+Initial lookup (miss): 82-93(84.8+/-4.2) ns
-Initial lookup (random): 111-115(112.6+/-1.6) ns
+Initial lookup (random): 118-138(123.4+/-7.4) ns
-Initial delete all: 66-68(66.6+/-0.8) ns
+Initial delete all: 79-90(82+/-4.1) ns
-Initial re-inserting: 87-90(88+/-1.3) ns
+Initial re-inserting: 104-116(107.2+/-4.4) ns
-Deleting first half: 32-33(32.4+/-0.49) ns
+Deleting first half: 37-43(39+/-2.1) ns
-Lookup after half-change (match): 67-69(68+/-0.89) ns
+Lookup after half-change (match): 72-81(74.2+/-3.4) ns
-Churning second time: 272-276(274.2+/-1.5) ns
+Churning second time: 304-332(310.2+/-11) ns
-Churning third time: 290-296(293+/-2) ns
+Churning third time: 233-259(239+/-10) ns
-Churning fourth time: 289-295(292+/-2.2) ns
+Churning fourth time: 309-337(315.6+/-11) ns
-Churning fifth time: 289-294(291.8+/-1.9) ns
+Churning fifth time: 307-337(315+/-11) ns
-Details: worst run 146 (24 deleted)
+Details: worst run 115 (2 deleted)
-Lookup after churn & spread (miss): 110-111(110.6+/-0.49) ns
+Lookup after churn & spread (miss): 93-104(95.4+/-4.3) ns
-Deleting half after churn & spread: 36-37(36.4+/-0.49) ns
+Deleting half after churn & spread: 39-45(40.4+/-2.3) ns
-Adding (a different) half after churn & spread: 81-82(81.6+/-0.49) ns
+Adding (a different) half after churn & spread: 38-43(39.6+/-1.7) ns
```

Signed-off-by: Rusty Russell <rusty@rustcorp.com.au>
ccan/htable/htable.c